Home » Substitute » 6 Substitutes For Green Pepper In Spaghetti Sauce

6 Substitutes For Green Pepper In Spaghetti Sauce

We all know that green peppers are a classic addition to spaghetti sauce. However, there are times when you don’t have any on hand or can’t find them anywhere! This is where substitutions come in handy. I have secret ingredients that can act as substitutes for green pepper in spaghetti sauce. I promise it is so good!

Making spaghetti sauce is a great way to use up leftover tomatoes and vegetables. When making your own, it’s also easy to substitute for green pepper with other veggies like Cubanelles or Anaheim Paper.

Substitution For Green Pepper In Spaghetti Sauce

  1. Tomato
  2. Schezwan Sauce
  3. Cubanelles
  4. Anaheim Pepper
  5. Pimiento Paper
  6. Shallots

1. Tomato

Tomato: substitutes for green pepper in spaghetti sauce

Tomato is an excellent substitute for green bell pepper. It adds the same flavor. Plus, it’s cheaper than green peppers too!

If you want to try out this new ingredient, add one can of tomato paste to your next batch of spaghetti sauce. We bet that once you taste how delicious it is, you won’t go back to using green peppers ever again! This simple change will make your meals healthier and tastier at the same time. What could be better than that?

The best matter about this substitution is that it doesn’t change the flavor or texture, so you won’t be able to tell the distinction between your old recipe and this new one. Your family will think they are eating their favorite meal again without knowing any difference, which means less stress for everyone involved.

Look out for more: Substitutes For Green Pepper In Casseroles

2. Schezwan Sauce

Schezwan Sauce is one of the substitutes for green pepper in spaghetti sauce

Spaghetti sauce is a great way to add flavor and spice to your favorite meals. But sometimes, it can be too bland or not spicy enough for you. You don’t have time for bland food anymore, so why not try something new? With just one squeeze of our bottle, you can transform your favorite meals into spicy masterpieces!

Schezwan Sauce is a perfect substitute for green pepper in spaghetti sauce that adds the appropriate amount of heat and flavor without overpowering the dish. Now you don’t have to settle for boring old spaghetti sauce! You can make your delicious dishes with this fantastic product from Schezwan Sauce!

Get more substitutes: Alternatives For Ponzu Sauce.

3. Cubanelles


We know you love cooking, and we want to help you make the best meal ever! That’s why Cubanelles – an all-natural substitute for green pepper in spaghetti sauce that will add a delicious kick of flavor to any dish. Check out Substitutes For Green Pepper In Soup

Cubanelles are round and sweet like green pepper but without needless acidity. All you require is to include them simultaneously as your other ingredients and let them simmer for 22 minutes so that they become soft. It’s that simple! You can find our recipe book here.

If you want to make spaghetti sauce even better than before, then try adding Cubanelles today! These little guys will give your dish an extra kick of flavor without all those pesky seeds and stringy pieces of green pepper getting stuck in your teeth as traditional peppers do. 

Check out more Cubanelle peppers alternatives.

4. Anaheim Pepper

Anaheim Pepper

Anaheim paper has been used for years by professional chefs in restaurants worldwide to add flavor and texture to their dishes without having to use expensive or hard-to-find ingredients. If you’ve ever craved an actual Italian dish but didn’t have any green peppers on hand, Anaheim Paper is the right thing to thicken up your spaghetti sauce. Without adding extra cheddar or mozzarella cheese for creaminess!

Again spiciness is vital to your Mexican food because, after all, what’s hotter than a spicy sauce? Give your bland red sauce some spice with Anaheim Paper. You can also use Anaheim Paper in pasta dishes for rotini and penne and many Asian dishes, including Pad Thai or General Tso Chicken.

Find out more: Top Substitutes for Serrano Peppers.

5. Pimiento Paper

Pimiento Paper

So what if you don’t like green peppers? So many people love ’em! But, spaghetti sauce with red pepper can be a cold dish for those who prefer something milder. Pimiento Paper is the solution; we use flavorless ginger root to simulate that traditional taste of bell peppers! Say farewell to bland spaghetti sauce – it’s time to spice up your dinners!

Mamas, don’t forget to stock up on Pimiento Paper! Cook your spaghetti with the same zesty ingredient but WITHOUT all of that green pepper!

Get more substitutes: Peppadew Substitutes.

6. Shallots

Shallots are substitutes for green pepper in spaghetti sauce

We know you’re trying to save money, so we want to help. Shallots, those clever little oniony veggies, make an excellent replacement for green pepper in spaghetti sauce. It pairs well with fennel and asparagus, and they’ll give your dish that extra kick of flavor without breaking the bank! They are also suitable in salads or as a side dish with any meal. You can even use them in place of garlic if you don’t have any on hand!

If you love cooking but hate spending all your time at the grocery store, then this is the product for you. It will make preparing meals more effortless than ever before, and it tastes delicious too! Just add some shallots into whatever recipe calls for green peppers and enjoy saving money while still getting excellent results from every meal. What could be better?

Find out more: Best Substitutes For Shallots.


What vegetable can you substitute for green pepper

Parsley, bok choy, bell peppers, or guacamole. Some people say substituting carrots work well. I haven’t tried it yet, though.
The veggies suggested are popular substitutes for green pepper in dishes like Thai curry and pasta primavera’s because of their spiciness and tangy vegetal flavor that balances the acidic tomatoes of these dishes. And while parsley is an excellent suggestion that can be used to substitute green pepper for all sorts of recipes, here are three easy ideas below to use if you’re feeling less adventurous than wanting to cook with parsley all by itself.
One option may be cooking with carrots instead of green peppers when they are in season. 

What may I substitute if I don’t have peppers?

Red onion
Tear into quarters and put in the skillet on medium heat with oil. Add some balsamic vinegar, salt, and pepper. Bring to the boil, stirring the onions until they are transparent (about 5-10 mins). Add basil leaves to wilt them. Remove from heat when ready.
Green beans work too but aren’t as gritty tasting or as spicy, so a jar of store-bought chili sauce, make your own by blending cayenne peppers with a bit of water in a food processor until chunky paste forms instead- can be made hot or mild) make a small amount at a time because these peppers will keep for months in the fridge.) Pesto is also a substitute for pepper. 

Can I substitute jalapeno for green pepper?

Yes, but it’s always best to experiment with different peppers to find sweet or spicy peppers.
You can substitute the green pepper with any other type of pepper you want, but it depends on what flavor you are after. A jalapeno is usually more bitter than a green pepper, so go for the jalapeno if you want that bite of spiciness. If you prefer a little bit more of an earthy taste, then experiment with some bell peppers instead. It is always amazing to try out different flavors until your taste buds are satisfied! You have no idea what will go well together until you give it a try!

What is a replacement for green pepper?

Add some red pepper. One teaspoon can speak volumes on the plate while adding spiciness to any dish. Red peppers are not only tasty, they’re loaded with powerful antioxidants and anti-inflammatory substances that fight cardiac disease, cancer, and even the common cold. They work best in dishes like soups, sauces, and stews, where their flavor is blended with other ingredients. They also make a terrific garnish for salads, sandwiches, and pizza slices (chop up equal parts of green pepper). Furthermore, red peppers are very raw when pitted or diced into strips or rings in salsas, stir-fries, or vegetable fajitas. 
Cherry tomatoes are often used too due to their availability. 

Should I put onions in my pasta sauce?

The flavor of onions in a sauce is terrific and adds depth to the taste.
An onion starts sweet but slowly becomes distinctly savory, making them perfect for sauces that are to be cooked slowly for hours. The sweetness lessens the acidity of tomatoes. Caramelization also helps reduce acidity while adding sweetness at the same time.
So have no fear—growing up with mothers who put onions in their sauce every night made me quite an expert–as long as you don’t chop them TOO small, so they cook down before your pasta boils to mush, it’s hard to go wrong! And if you are using canned tomatoes, which are already acidic, it doesn’t suit the sauce. 

What can I add to my homemade spaghetti sauce to make it taste better?

You can add olive oil, garlic, chopped onions, basil, oregano, and black pepper to make it taste better.
High-heat oil can’t tolerate any water exposure without breaking down. So things like fresh herbs will need to be added after cooking or sprinkled on top of your spaghetti dish once it’s already in the bowl.

What can I substitute for green onions?

You can substitute leeks if the recipe’s not too picky and insists on a green, or you can use chopped scallions. Sometimes celery does the job, but it will give your dish a completely different taste. If all else, try using Italian parsley as an herb with olive oil and garlic as a condiment instead of chopping into your pasta sauce or mashed potatoes. You’ll find that most recipes work just fine without this one ingredient – only picky cooks might notice any difference!

Do Italians use onion in sauce?

Italian garlic and onion sauces (like pesto or rosé) can include either onions or garlic, but not both. There are some slight differences in the taste when they’re used together, whereas using just one of them is more neutral. There’s also a difference in texture; when using two kinds, the finished product tends to be heartier and more like a purée than if you were only cooking with one type. 
Some Italian cooks swear by combining the two pastes in various proportions to keep oregano’s flavor from becoming too strong; they use anywhere from ¼ tsp to ½ tsp for every cloves garlic.

Can you put raw onions in spaghetti sauce?

Yes, but the onion may cause the sauce to darken if it spends too long in the pot.
The colors of a spaghetti sauce often depend on what vegetables are used in its preparation, so adding an onion could potentially color a spaghetti sauce a deeper brown. Adding raw onions at a time other than during cooking would change nothing about the finished dish’s appearance, flavor, or texture. So you can put raw onions into your spaghetti sauce just fine – just don’t be surprised when that happens. Basically, it’s down to personal preference – if you want lighter-colored food, add canned ingredients instead!

What kind of onions are best for spaghetti sauce

I recommend using green onions because they are sweeter than onions used in other dishes. However, the red onion will also work well with the spaghetti sauce recipe!
If you’re adding celery to your sauce, I would also add ¼ teaspoon of salt for every cup. You can reduce or eliminate this amount if you choose not to use celery in the dish. Minced garlic is a fantastic ingredient that adds flavor to this dish. Start with one clove per jar and work up from there, depending on your taste! If you enjoy spices, I recommend Hungarian paprika powder for some zing–add about ½ teaspoon per jar when cooking it on medium-low heat for 25 minutes over medium-high heat until it is cooked.

Conclusion :  

Are you looking for a substitute for green pepper in spaghetti sauce? You can use any of these ingredients to make your version. Which one will you try first? What are some other substitutes that you like to use when making pasta dishes at home? Please share your thoughts with us on social media! We love hearing from our readers and followers.

Scroll to Top