Home » Substitute » 5 Substitutes For Green Pepper In Sloppy Joes

5 Substitutes For Green Pepper In Sloppy Joes

I don’t know about your choice, but I am not a big fan of green peppers. I like them so little that I usually substitute them in sloppy joes with other vegetables or meat. Tons of vegetables can be used as substitutes for green pepper in sloppy joes.

I’ve been looking for a way to make sloppy joes without green peppers, but I haven’t found the perfect recipe. But in this article, I have discussed some substitute for green pepper in sloppy joes that is close enough that I can barely taste the difference in the recipe.

Substitutes For Green Pepper In Sloppy Joes

  1. Red Onion
  2. Green Chili
  3. Jalapenos
  4. Paprika
  5. Chili Flex

1. Red Onion

Red Onion: substitutes for green pepper in sloppy joes

Have you ever wondered what makes a sloppy joe so delicious? It’s the red onion! The red onion is the secret ingredient that gives your sloppy joes their unique flavor. You can use it in place of green bell peppers to add a little something extra to your dish. We all know that red onion is sweetened when the green pepper has a pale taste, So red onion is perfect with ground beef. Check out Substitutes For Green Pepper In Meatloaf

This ingredient not only packs a fiery punch but has the added benefit of creating healthier dishes. Try using it today and see how much better your meals taste with this simple substitution. Your family will love you for it!

Get more substitutes: Pearl Onions Alternatives.

2. Green Chili

Green Chili is one of the substitutes for green pepper in sloppy joes

Do you want to make your sloppy joes spicier?

We know that sometimes, it can be hard to find the right balance between a little bit of spice and too much. That’s why we recommend using Green Chili in your following recipe instead of green bell pepper. It’ll give you just the right amount of kick without being overwhelming. Plus, it adds a nice fresh flavor to your dish!

Green Chili is a great ingredient to use in cooking to spice up any recipe! Mix up your ground beef with some green chilies, onions, and garlic and add to any dish, and it will pack a punch for sure! So if you’re looking to make your food even hotter than usual this time around, we recommend investing in some Green Chili.

Don’t worry! This will be too hot for anyone at dinner tonight – so invite everyone over and get cooking! Your family will love the mindblowing taste, and they might even ask for seconds (or thirds). After all, who doesn’t like a good sloppy joe? 

Get more substitutes: Substitutes For Poblano Peppers

3. Jalapenos

Jalapenos: substitutes for green pepper in sloppy joes

Do you want to make your sloppy joes spicier?

Jalapenos are a great way to add some spice and flavor to any dish. They also have a good number of vitamins A, C, and K. You can use them in salsa, guacamole, or even on top of nachos! We recommend adding jalapenos into your following recipe for an extra kick.

Just an essential ingredient will do the trick to your meat mixture– no need for complicated recipes that take up all of your time! Plus, it’s super easy – chop them up and throw some of these spicy chunks of heat into your sloppy joe set up and prepare for a truly adventurous day!! Ready to set your food on fire? Jalapeño slices pack a powerful punch and will turn your favorite recipe into something you’ll never forget.

Check out more substitutes for Jalapeno Pepper.

4. Paprika

We’re in food, so we know that the best recipes are the ones that have been passed down from generation to generation. We recommend you to try marinating paprika to the lean ground beef to give your sloppy joe recipe for a smokey experience like no other.

With one pound of distinctive seasoning, you will get enough for 10-30 servings. It is perfect for adding smoky substance to any meal, and it’s a great way to expand your specialty food recipes that everyone loves!

You can use paprika instead of green bell pepper paper to give your recipe a smoky taste without adding extra ingredients or spending time chopping up vegetables. It’s easy and tastes great! Now you can create a fantastic dish for your family in just minutes. Enjoy delicious food with your families together.

5. Chili Flex

Chili Flakes

Do you want to add a kick of spice to your sloppy joes?

You can use Chili Flex instead of green bell peppers to give the recipe a spicy taste. Adding chili flex is an easy way to make your favorite dish even better!

Chili Flex is a product that lets you add spicy flavor to your favorite foods without all the fuss. Just sprinkle a pinch of chili flex on top of your food, and voila – deliciousness in an instant! It’s easy, convenient, and makes cooking fun again. And now it comes in three flavors, so there’s something for everyone!


What can I use instead of green pepper?

Proper green peppers can be challenging to find, depending on your location. If you live close to Mexico, Central America, or South America, you might be in luck. Otherwise, many people use bell peppers instead of this raw vegetable that is not very common yet in the US.

Another suggestion could be Mexican chilies which are spicy but have great flavor for tacos and salads. The best recommendation will be to buy a jar of pickled jalapeños if they are available at your local grocery store or even the deli/bakery section there. They are typically located near any recipe creations with Mexican influences so check out what other Hispanic food options!

What vegetable can you substitute for green pepper?

Radishes are a little much in terms of spice level when raw, but they become very nicely flavored when cooked. Just think of them as doing the purple version of green pepper.
Spicy cooling cucumbers can be substituted.

Zucchini is a relatively sturdy and neutral-flavored vegetable that can substitute for green pepper. You’ll need to soak the zucchini first for it to cook through before using it as a substitute, though.
It’s pretty challenging to do this with many vegetables because they have very different flavors and textures.

Still, zucchini works pretty well as an alternative since its taste and texture are similar to green pepper. To soften zucchini first, you will first want to briefly soak the slices for about 15 minutes before adding them into the dish or cooking them on their own since most vegetables don’t gain much from blanching. 

Can I use paprika replacement for bell pepper?

Yes, one can use paprika instead. Paprika tastes like a bell pepper substitute.
Paprika is made by grinding fruits, seeds, and spices with cloves, peppers, sugar, and vinegar. Most paprika contains peppers that are ground into a pulp or purée, but some also contain other ingredients, including onions or tomatoes. The peppers give the paprika its distinctively sweetened smoky flavor.

Always use fresh spices when cooking. Whole spices can last for up to three years, but once they are ground, they lose their fragrance fast! When substituting dried herbs for fresh ones, make sure there’s twice as much dried herb as you would typically use – because it will be four times less potent than fresh herbs! If at all

Can I use red pepper in lieu of green?

Red bell peppers can be substituted in place of green bell peppers.
It has the same taste but is sweeter. The texture is also less crunchy than green or yellow peppers. You also need to add more red pepper than green pepper if you want it to be good (just like all vegetables).
Red peppers might even last longer because they go bad slower; some say red peppers will always outlive yellow and green bells in freshness. There are many different bell peppers, so there’s no way for me to know which tastes better than the other, but I do believe that my campers at least seem to enjoy the taste the best!

Can you use black pepper instead of green bell paper 

Surprisingly, YES.
Some people replace parsley for black pepper on an omelet or simply use black pepper instead of green bell peppers on a salad. Some people also enjoy shaking a few flakes into their stir fry.

The flavors are a bit different, but I find that many people find it preferable to use the pepper instead of the fresh herbs because they’re not put off by the heat from pure pepper compared to liters of dressing and chopped garlic/shallots/onions from all those different herbs added together. It’s easier to add flavor with just one spice or ingredient at a time rather than trying to go through so many possibilities at once when cooking your food from scratch.

How do I soak zucchini to soften it before cooking?

Slice the zucchini into rounds no thicker than 1/4 inch.
Please put it in a pot or bowl of cold water with ice cubes, let it rest for 10 minutes, then drain off the water. Sprinkle salt on one side when it’s drained and wipe away. Blot dry in paper towels before cooking. 

Pour one tablespoon olive oil into a pan to cover the bottom in an even layer, heat to medium-low heat, and add both sides of sliced zucchini cut-side down until golden brown. Add onions after 5 minutes on medium-low heat if desired, turn zucchini over, so both sides are cooked through but not browned- about 6 -8 min.

For more giant zucchinis, both were boiling and simmering work well for softening them up before cooking. For smaller zucchini slices, use this technique which is more effective at getting rid of all that excess water that’s stored inside the squash–without having to cut into it first! Boil or simmer your slices for about two minutes first, then let them sit wet on a covered place.


 If you are searching for an idea to get rid of green pepper in sloppy joes or just want several new ideas on how you can use other ingredients instead, consider the following substitutes. The first idea is to substitute green bell peppers for green chili or jalapeno.

Bell peppers have similar flavor profiles, but they’re not as spicy, and their texture isn’t quite so crunchy, which might be an improvement depending on your preference! Another option would be paprika. Paprika has a smoky flavor that blends well with most foods without taking over the dish like green pepper sometimes does. Finally, if neither of these options seems appealing, there are always alternatives such as red onion that are crunchy and add a mildly sweet flavor to the recipe.

Scroll to Top